Comparison · Shopify review apps
Judge.me vs Loox: Which Review App for Shopify in 2026?
Both Judge.me and Loox are Built-for-Shopify review apps with strong ratings, but they make very different tradeoffs on free-tier generosity, pricing, and visual presentation. This comparison walks through the real differences — verified against current 2026 App Store pricing — so you can pick the one that actually fits your store, not the one with the louder marketing.
Verified against current App Store + pricing pages on May 12, 2026
Quick verdict
Judge.me for most stores, especially budget-conscious ones (its Forever Free plan is significantly more generous). Loox if you specifically want polished photo/video review presentation and have $50+/month budget.
At-a-glance
Feature-by-feature
Green highlight = winner on that dimension. Untied dimensions in plain text.
Judge.me
Forever Free with unlimited reviews and unlimited photo/video reviews. Most generous free tier in the Shopify review-app category.
Strengths
- Forever Free plan covers most stores' needs without any paid upgrade — unlimited reviews and unlimited media is rare in this category
- 5.0-star rating across 39,000+ App Store reviews — the highest review volume in the Shopify review category by a wide margin
- Built for Shopify performance badge
- Imports from competing platforms (Loox, Yotpo) so migration in is friction-free
- Google rich snippets included on free plan — star ratings can appear in Google search results within a few weeks of installing
Tradeoffs
- Visual design of widgets is functional but less polished than Loox by default — looks fine on most themes but doesn't WOW
- AI features locked behind the $15/month Awesome tier (Loox's photo/video presentation has no AI cost barrier)
- Some legacy parts of the dashboard UI feel dated compared to newer competitors
Best for
- Stores on tight budgets that need real review functionality without ongoing cost
- Stores with high review volume where unlimited matters more than presentation polish
- Stores that want Google rich snippet star ratings without paying for it
- Migrating off another platform (Judge.me's importer handles most sources)
Loox
Free plan exists but is capped at 100 review request emails per month and 500 total orders. Photo-focused visual design from the free tier up.
Strengths
- Visual polish — review widgets, especially photo-grid layouts, render with more design sophistication than Judge.me's defaults
- Photo and video reviews are the explicit product focus — visual social proof is the strongest use case
- Convert tier ($49.99/mo) bundles AI features that Judge.me charges separately for
- 4.9-star rating across 7,800+ reviews — strong sentiment despite a fraction of Judge.me's volume
- Built for Shopify badge
Tradeoffs
- Free plan order cap (500 orders total, then you have to upgrade) makes it impractical for any growing store
- Starting paid tier is $49.99/month — 3x Judge.me's Awesome plan with comparable AI features
- Order-based pricing on Convert tier ($50 per additional 300 orders) can scale faster than expected for high-volume stores
- Unlimited plan at $299.99/month puts Loox firmly in enterprise-pricing territory
Best for
- Visually-focused brands (fashion, accessories, beauty) where photo/video review presentation directly drives conversion
- Stores already on a Convert-tier budget that want all features in one app
- Brands with strong existing UGC photo culture that need a polished frame for it
- Stores under 500 orders total experimenting with Loox's free plan before scaling
How to choose
Choose Judge.me if…
- You're on a tight budget. Judge.me's Forever Free covers most stores' real needs — there's a credible path to never paying anything.
- You expect high review volume. Unlimited reviews + unlimited photo/video reviews on the free tier means you don't hit a wall as you scale.
- You want Google rich-snippet star ratings without paying for them. Free plan includes the markup needed.
- You're migrating from another platform. Judge.me's importer explicitly supports Loox, Yotpo, Amazon, Etsy, and AliExpress.
- You prioritize functionality over visual polish. The widgets work cleanly even if they're not the prettiest in the category.
Choose Loox if…
- Your brand is visually-driven (fashion, beauty, jewelry, art) and photo/video review presentation directly affects conversion.
- You have $50+/month review-app budget and want AI features (replies, sorting, translations) bundled in.
- You're under 500 orders total and want to test Loox's design polish before committing to a paid tier.
- Your existing customers already share lots of photos with reviews and you want a polished frame for that UGC.
- You value design and aesthetic consistency more than raw functionality and free-tier generosity.
Migration between the two
- Migration in either direction is supported. Judge.me's importer explicitly lists Loox as a supported source. Loox's free plan includes a generic reviews importer that handles Judge.me exports.
- When migrating from Loox to Judge.me: export your reviews from Loox first (CSV format), then use Judge.me's import wizard. Customer review timestamps are preserved.
- When migrating from Judge.me to Loox: export from Judge.me, import via Loox's wizard. Photo/video review media transfers but may need to be re-associated with the correct review on the destination.
- Pro tip: keep the old app installed for 30 days after migration so customers who land on cached review URLs still see the historical reviews. Then uninstall.
Related
Judge.me vs Yotpo comparison →
If Loox isn't the right fit either, Yotpo is the other major alternative — enterprise-tier reviews platform with loyalty/SMS/email ecosystem.
How to Add Customer Reviews to Shopify →
Full setup walkthrough for whichever app you pick — Judge.me settings + review request scheduling + widget placement.
Why reviews matter (methodology) →
The trust-signal research behind why reviews convert and why fake reviews backfire.
Not sure if reviews are your biggest gap?
Scan your Shopify store in 30 seconds and see which of the 14 trust signals are actually costing you conversions. Free, no signup.
Scan My Store — Free